Google’s rise to dominance and the changing industry culture
Google did not firmly establish itself as the accepted industry leader until around 2006 or 2007, and advertisers initially disliked its complex system. Google introduced the concept of “ad groups,” which forced marketers to transition from spending just a few hours a year on traditional advertising to managing digital campaigns on a weekly basis.
Ultimately, advertisers only adopted Google’s platform because its superior, user-centric search engine attracted the vast majority of internet traffic. Around the time Search Engine Land launched in 2006, the culture of the search industry was rapidly shifting from casual, basement-run operations into a mainstream corporate environment fueled by venture capital money, oversized salaries, and lavish private yacht parties.
Additionally, earlier days of the industry saw greater information sharing among professionals because there were fewer corporate lock-downs and NDAs compared to today.
Major milestones that changed PPC forever
Geddes points to two major turning points that permanently altered the paid search landscape. First, Google’s organic algorithm updates—Panda, Penguin, and Pigeon—made organic search highly complex, forcing marketers to realize they could no longer be generalists and had to specialize in either SEO or paid search.
The second major milestone was the successful implementation of automated bidding. Before this technology, bidding required tedious, transient work using Excel formulas. Automation freed up massive amounts of time for marketers to focus on creativity and strategic account management instead.
Furthermore, Geddes highlights a massive change in 2005 when Google decided to only allow one ad per domain on a search results page, which forced affiliate marketers to build dedicated landing pages and add real value to the user experience in order to survive.
Outdated tactics and missed platform features
Reflecting on older practices, Geddes expresses a strong dislike for Single Keyword Ad Groups (SKAGs), an over-segmentation strategy that once forced advertisers to build thousands of campaigns due to early platform limitations.
However, he does miss several features that are no longer available, such as the original Enhanced Cost-Per-Click (ECPC) that allowed advertisers to dictate the exact price they wanted to pay per click and have Google do the math.
He also misses hyper-specific geo-targeting tools that allowed marketers to draw custom radius points around specific interstates, as well as features that allowed custom ad adjustments for individual business locations.
AI misconceptions and the next 20 years of search
Looking toward the future, Geddes warns against the widespread misconception that artificial intelligence can completely run an advertising account. He argues that just as marketers shouldn’t blindly hit “accept all” on Google’s auto-applied recommendations, they shouldn’t hand total control over to AI because it can write both good and bad ads.
Over the next two decades, he predicts the industry will reward creativity, strategic tactics, and business optimization rather than basic “button-pushers”. Because marketing fundamentally relies on connecting with human beings—who often make illogical choices contrary to how an AI thinks—human creativity will remain critical.
Rapid-fire retrospective
When asked for quick thoughts on the industry, Geddes noted that a major prediction he got wrong was thinking mobile adoption would happen much faster than it actually did.
Conversely, he accurately predicted that voice search was overblown and would simply become part of normal search queries rather than a completely separate channel. He observed that Google rarely admits how the world actually functions today, preferring instead to market ideal future scenarios based on massive amounts of data that most advertisers don’t have.
Furthermore, he believes that PPC professionals rarely test their campaigns as much as they claim to. Finally, if he could give his younger self one piece of advice from 10 to 15 years ago, it would simply be to buy more Google stock.
Search Engine Land is owned by Semrush. We remain committed to providing high-quality coverage of marketing topics. Unless otherwise noted, this page’s content was written by either an employee or a paid contractor of Semrush Inc.
